The first thing we’ll probably do if our loved one is in the media is have a big emotion, right? — like when the cameraperson in the stadium puts you on the jumbotron.
Most of us will be excited. I was VERY excited when NPR discovered our Debt Annihilation Team and talked about them on two different podcasts, recently. I hope you saw the notice on the Covenant List:
- Marketplace. “This Is Uncomfortable,” Episode 23, Nov 14, 2019
- Kind World, “Is Everything OK?,” Nov 11, 2019
My loved ones sounded like their brilliant selves and our vision for following Jesus looked pretty great, too.
But sometimes you might feel puzzled, at best, and horrified, at worst, at how your loved ones gets twisted by inaccurate or unscrupulous reporting that will probably be on the internet forever. The first time I ever got my picture in the newspaper they said my name was “Tod.” They got both the dogs’ names correct, however.
Our most recent relationship with the powerful media was pretty great. NPR treated us generously. But I also feel disappointed with how the producer of “This is Uncomfortable” summed up our radicality in a way none of his subjects implied.
Here are two things to expect if your loved one is in the media.
It is going to be depersonalized while looking personal
The segment of Marketplace I heard was the 23rd in a series about “Life and how money messes with it.” “Life” is a thing” and “money” is a force. You’ve entered the media machine and it has a worldview. The show has a topic and you are being fit into it.
I kind of like the show’s point of view. We need to know that the average amount for people with credit card debt is over $6000. They said our team was “turning to a very ancient text, the Bible, to solve a very modern problem.” That’s all great.
Caroline Butcher sounded like a very charming, sincere person. The story of her troubles, joys, problems, and hopes was inspiring. They said saving, and living within one’s means is a social act. They showed how sincere the group was about not compromising their Integrity. Caroline said the money helped her finances, but maybe even more profound, the group helped her change her view from “me” to “us.” When the reporter outed her in the Sunday meeting she owned her place on the usually-anonymous DAT — that made her shame lose some power, which might be the most profound experience of all. So that was all good.
I was impressed how love and hope kept leaking through the carefully-flat presentation of the format.
The producer will have a way of inserting their agenda which does not match what you said
There was really only one line in the segment that made me sigh with disappointment and a little bit of irritation. It was this:
“What’s so radical about that church’s system to pay off debt is that God doesn’t actually have to be a part of it. It’s really just a community helping each other out.”
Nobody said anything like that. God was a main player in all of it. It is hard to come to his conclusion from what he presented himself!
On the one hand, it’s true. We would like to help people who don’t trust Jesus and his people. Being mutual with them would be great. Community is powerful. But I don’t think the producer meant to say just that. He was interested in the radicality of having community, not knowing God. He pointedly took God out of the question, for some reason.
So on the other hand what he said wasn’t true and was just plain poor reporting. He tweaked the whole thing on the sign off, after Caroline was up front about her faith journey, after people had allowed him to record them praying, and after Joshua gave a dandy explanation of the Debt Annihilation Team’s biblical foundation in a few sentences. All the people in the piece were open and vulnerable with their faith and the author summed it up with “Faith doesn’t matter anyway; this is all about people getting together, not God.”
Most of us wake up every day with some indecision about what matters or whether we even matter. So I can give the producer, Peter Balonon-Rosen, a pass on his conclusion. Most listeners probably listened to his summary and wondered what people he had listened to, anyway, like I did. But he would probably be a fine dinner guest.
When you get involved with the media, don’t be surprised if the producers produce what they want with the raw material of your story. They’re running a big machine looking for stuff to process and the machine has some big assumptions to organize our thinking — on purpose or unwittingly.